New Arrivals/Restock

AmishTastes Bird-in-Hand Bake Shop Homemade Wet-Bottom Shoofly Pie, Favorite Amish Food, 9" Diameter/28 Oz. (Pack of 2)

flash sale iconLimited Time Sale
Until the end
17
41
34

$27.59 cheaper than the new price!!

Free shipping for purchases over $99 ( Details )
Free cash-on-delivery fees for purchases over $99
Please note that the sales price and tax displayed may differ between online and in-store. Also, the product may be out of stock in-store.
New  $45.99
quantity

Product details

Management number 220190888 Release Date 2026/05/03 List Price $18.40 Model Number 220190888
Category

Brought to you by AmishTastes, here is the classic Amish-style, wet-bottom Shoofly Pie, baked at the Bird-in-Hand Bake Shop on Gibbons Road just outside the village of Bird-in-Hand. The Bake Shop produces premium baked goods and is well-known for its homemade, old fashioned, wet-bottom shoofly pies. A “wet bottom” shoofly pie has a gooey molasses bottom, cake-like middle and crumb topping. For those of us who have that irresistible sweet tooth, Wet-Bottom Shoofly Pie is a "must have". The shoofly pie is by far the most popular dessert made by the Amish here in Lancaster County! If you are like us, you'll find it's hard to stop with just one slice. Shoofly pies are packed in a white bakery box of heavy cardboard for safe shipping.

  • Made in the USA; This premium, homemade, "gooey" Shoofly Pie is baked by the Bird-in-Hand Bake Shop in Pennsylvania's Amish country
  • For pies made by Smucker’s Bird-in-Hand Bakery along Rt. 340, search Amazon for item B09XC2YMVT
  • This Wet-Bottom Style Shoofly Pie with Crumb Top Is a Favorite Amish and Mennonite Dessert
  • Each 6” Pie provides 3-4 servings; Each 9" Pie provides around 7 servings
  • Can be frozen for long storage; Packed in a white bakery-style box of heavy cardboard to help ensure safe shipping
Units 56 Ounce
Manufacturer Bird-in-Hand Bake Shop
Package Dimensions 14.75 x 11.75 x 0.5 inches; 6 Pounds

Correction of product information

If you notice any omissions or errors in the product information on this page, please use the correction request form below.

Correction Request Form

Product Review

You must be logged in to post a review